Rocky Road to Utopia:
'Ever After'
Shane Lewis

Twentieth Century Fox 1998, directed by Andy Tennant


11 Jan. 99

Bit 1 In Ever After, living happily ever after is the destiny of Danielle, the girl who sweeps up the cinders, and Henry, the handsome prince; but they must first overcome obstacles on their road to Utopia.
Bit 2 Making use of the popular twentieth-century notion of "Utopia" in a sixteenth-century story is one of the little liberties Ever After writers Susannah Grant, Andy Tennant and Rick Parks have taken to give texture to their Cinderella story.
Bit 3 In a prologue to the romance, Auguste (Jeroën Krabbé), widowed father of eight-year-old Danielle, returns from a journey with a new stepmother and stepsisters for his daughter. Besides having her father back home, the biggest thrill for the little girl is his homecoming gift of a brand-new copy of Sir Thomas More's Utopia. Auguste's death leaves Danielle to the mercy of her stepmother Rodmilla (Anjelica Huston), but when we meet the grown-up Danielle (Drew Barrymore) ten years later, her few comforts include the well-thumbed copy of Utopia.
Bit 4 Utopia was first published (in Latin) in 1516, and reprinted five times over the next three years. So it seems that the romance of Danielle and Prince Henry (Dougray Scott) probably gets off the ground slightly before 1530. The plot stresses the importance of the book as linking love, learning, and love of learning.
Bit 5 First, Utopia is the device that allows Prince Henry to recognise Danielle's learning when, seeking to buy the release of a faithful retainer sold to pay Rodmilla's debts, she quotes from it. Through this plot point, Danielle and Henry discover the love of learning they have in common. Second, the book is half of the terrible choice Rodmilla offers her when stepdaughter Marguerite (Megan Dodds) wants to seize the jewelled slippers Danielle's mother left to her: "Your father's book, or your mother's shoes!" In any case, the precious book is consigned to the fire.
Bit 6 Danielle's earlier speech when she wants freedom for the servant, her evident learning, and her spunky behaviour lend a contemporary aura to her "Bible", Utopia (and the film), in line with a now-common, though erroneous view of Thomas More as a socialist and "Utopia" as a paradise. But though More described equality and shared resources in his invented society, and advocated the female education he practised in his family, "Utopia" (he invented the word) was hardly Shangri-La, and women's education was not to give them careers, but to bring honour to their households.
Bit 7 There's a bit more artistic licence in a little juggling of dates engaged in by Grant, Tennant and Parks to make a good story. In the year Danielle and Prince Henry meet, according to the script, Leonardo da Vinci arrives in the French countryside, telling Danielle that King Francis (Timothy West) has given him a court appointment -- and he's the lucky candidate, as the other contender Michelangelo is busy (working on the Sistine Chapel). Francis I, king of France between 1515 and 1547, was succeeded by his son Henry, who ruled from 1547 to 1559. Leonardo da Vinci spent the last two years of his life (1517-1519) in France, in a chateau near the court residence of Amboise, at the invitation of Francis I, owner of the Mona Lisa. Michelangelo was tied up even earlier, painting the Sistine Chapel between 1508 and 1512.
Bit 8 In another plug by the writers for freedom and equality, they have Henry asking Danielle why she isn't in church; when she says something to the effect that her faith does not need such surroundings, he says, "I'm afraid my father's edict has created quite a phenomenon". In 1535 Francis I issued the Edict of Coucy (an amnesty for religious prisoners and exiles), extending it the next year to all heretics; however, this did not mean the religious tolerance the script suggests.
Bit 9 But this is a romantic comedy, not a Renaissance history lesson, and so we can also overlook modern dialogue along the lines of "I guess we'll never know", "they'll never buy it", or "you've got bigger problems" -- all designed to make today's viewers identify with the characters, and not alienate them with a lot of thees and 'tweres. Our suspicions that Pierre Le Pieu (Richard O'Brien) is a really creepy suitor for Danielle are also confirmed because in the script Pieu is pronounced "pew".
Bit 10 At the end of all good pantomimes, when all are lined up, the good and the bad, the formula "all is forgiven" is spoken, and the bad become good; and they all live happily ever after. In Ever After, when our last sight of the beauteous Barrymore and her Leonardo da Vinci portrait is of a face radiating goodness, we know that grudges will not be held as the way is made straight for the lovers' progress to happiness ever after.

Bit 11 Details

Ever After, by Twentieth Century Fox, 1998.
Director: Andy Tennant.
Screenplay: Susannah Grant, Andy Tennant, Rick Parks.
Cinematography: Andrew Dunn.
Production Design: Michael Howells.
Costume Design: Jenny Beavan.
Cast: Drew Barrymore, Anjelica Huston, Dougray Scott, Megan Dodds, Richard O'Brien.


Bit 12 Citation reference for this article

MLA style:
Shane Lewis. "Rocky Road to Utopia: 'Ever After'." M/C Reviews 9 Jan. 99. [your date of access] <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/ever.html>.

Chicago style:
Shane Lewis, "Rocky Road to Utopia: 'Ever After'," M/C Reviews 9 Jan. 99, <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/ever.html> ([your date of access]).

APA style:
Shane Lewis. (1999) Rocky road to Utopia: 'Ever After'. M/C Reviews 9 Jan. 99. <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/ever.html> ([your date of access]).

M/C Reviews main index

M/C

contributors

responses

about M/C Reviews

about UQ

contacts & links

support M/C!

respond to this review


copyright © M/C


[image]