Nice Guys Win: A Fairytale --
'Big Daddy'/'Election'
Shane Lewis

Big Daddy, by Columbia 1999, directed by Dennis Dugan / Election, by United International Pictures 1999, directed by Alexander Payne


16 Oct. 99

Bit 1 If you went by the trailer, you would think Big Daddy was a collection of gross-out moments somehow tied together by a loudmouthed Adam Sandler. This type of promotion seems to be aimed at getting teenage boys (that important market segment) to buy tickets -- after all, would they buy tickets to a story about family and love?
Bit 2 But these concerns are at the heart of the Adam Sandler characters, in a series of films written by Tim Herlihy, usually with Sandler, and here with Steve Franks as lead screenwriter.
Bit 3 Big Daddy is another fairytale where a decent, if childlike, thirtyish hero has to face a hostile world and find a way to assert the things he believes in: family ties and the value of love. In Happy Gilmore, Hap had to find a way of getting money to save his Grandma's house being sold for back taxes; in The Water Boy, Bobby Boucher lived in a fairytale cabin on the bayou with his Mama while searching for a niche in life; in The Wedding Singer Robbie Hart had to protect his princess from a sleazebag adulterer. And in Big Daddy, Sonny Koufax must ultimately reunite/create families.
Bit 4 Sonny Koufax (Sandler) takes a special delivery from Social Services of a five-year-old boy called Julian (Cole and Dylan Sprouse), the product of a college-days fling by his current roommate and past fellow student, Kevin (Jon Stewart). Sonny loyally pretends to be the child's father while attorney Kevin is away on business before his wedding to doctor Corinne (Leslie Mann).
Bit 5 Playing Dad, Sonny shares the juvenile pastimes of his idle lifestyle -- funded by compensation for an accident -- with the tot, while discovering an interest in Corinne's sister, Layla (Joey Lauren Adams); however, the film's biggest laughs come not from the schoolboy "mucking up" -- the food messes and bodily functions in the scenes being promoted -- but from the set pieces involving the adult characters, like cameos from Steve Buscemi and director Dennis Dugan and the hysterical courtroom scene, the custody hearing to decide Julian's fate.
Bit 6 In the Adam Sandler world, his character tries to behave decently, and is ultimately rewarded; so we know they're fairytales. In the world of Election, decent behaviour seems to be a mortal impossibility, greed is good, and the richest rewards can go to the canniest manipulators.
Bit 7 Though set in a high school, Election is not a "high school comedy" any more than the satirical Rushmore was, or any more than the setting defines a situation comedy. Remorseless and often howlingly funny, its screenplay provides Matthew Broderick with his best role in a long time.
Bit 8 As in Peyton Place, passions percolate behind a neat exterior in Election -- behind the middle American face of Omaha, Nebraska, and one of its typical local high school communities. Forbidden relationships, blind ambition, revenge, rocketing ascent and bottomless falls await the desperate characters to be found here.
Bit 9 Dedicated teacher Jim McAllister (Broderick) loses a friend when fellow teacher Dave Novotny (Mark Harelik) destroys his marriage and leaves town following an affair with nobody's pet, the school's ace crawler, Tracy Flick (Reese Witherspoon). When Tracy decides to stand for student president, Jim makes sure it won't be a walkover by flattering dumb jock Paul Metzler (Chris Klein) into standing for office as Tracy's opponent.
Bit 10 The race gets complicated after the girl chosen by Paul's sister Tammy (Jessica Campbell) as her soulmate tires of Tammy's passion, throws her over, and gets even by seducing Paul. The jilted Tammy takes revenge by announcing her candidacy, and immediately wins over the student body by her platform of abolishing student government. While the campaign race moves into dirty tricks gear, Jim thinks he sees a chance to improve his grim love life by pursuing Dave's abandoned wife, Linda (Delaney Driscoll).
Bit 11 Although Jim tries to teach ethics and morals to his high school students, no-one in the film seems to have learned what's involved, including the teacher. To teach such lessons, you often need a fairytale: there, as in Big Daddy, nice guys win; and bad girls (like Tracy in Election) finish last -- or at least they would, if Sandler pictures had any real bad girls, or if they didn't forgive everyone at the end ...

Bit 12 Details

Big Daddy, by Columbia 1999.
Director: Dennis Dugan.
Screenplay: Steve Franks, Tim Herlihy and Adam Sandler.
Cinematographer: Theo van de Sande.
Production Designer: Perry Andelin Blake.
Costume Designer: Ellen Lutter.
Cast: Adam Sandler, Joey Lauren Adams, Jon Stewart, Rob Schneider, Cole and Dylan Sprouse, Allen Covert, Leslie Mann, Joseph Bologna, Steve Buscemi.

Election, by United International Pictures 1999.
Director: Alexander Payne.
Screenplay: Alexander Payne and Jim Taylor, from the novel by Tom Perrotta.
Cinematographer: James Glennon.
Production Designer: Jane Ann Stewart.
Costume Designer: Wendy Chuck.
Cast: Matthew Broderick, Reese Witherspoon, Chris Klein, Jessica Campbell, Mark Harelik, Phil Reeves.


Bit 13 Citation reference for this article

MLA style:
Shane Lewis. "Nice Guys Win: A Fairytale -- 'Big Daddy'/'Election'." M/C Reviews 16 Oct. 99. [your date of access] <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/comedy.html>.

Chicago style:
Shane Lewis, "Nice Guys Win: A Fairytale -- 'Big Daddy'/'Election'," M/C Reviews 16 Oct. 99, <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/comedy.html> ([your date of access]).

APA style:
Shane Lewis. (1999) Nice guys win: a fairytale -- 'Big daddy'/'Election'. M/C Reviews 16 Oct. 99. <http://www.uq.edu.au/mc/reviews/screen/comedy.html> ([your date of access]).

M/C Reviews main index

M/C

contributors

responses

about M/C Reviews

about UQ

contacts & links

support M/C!

respond to this review


copyright © M/C


[image]